Home/Resources/Identification, Measurement, and Counterfactual Reasoning

Identification, Measurement, and Counterfactual Reasoning

This book defines the observable object, the counterfactual target, and the information a representation must preserve. It connects exact identification, local repair, approximate loss, measurement across environments, timing error, administrative transmission, and model comparison through one target-directed language.

16 chapters80 focused topics

Observation, Representation, and Sufficiency

I-01

Define the Research Object as a Contract

A counterfactual question becomes precise only after the structural state, observation rule, policy set, horizon, target, loss, and admissible records are fixed. The chapter treats that list as a research contract and separates within-model policy comparisons from comparisons across model families.

  1. Structure, observations, and targets
  2. The state-design contract
  3. Units of counterfactual comparison
  4. Quantifiers and domains
  5. Types of evidence
→
I-02

Linear Maps, Kernels, Quotients, and Information Dimension

Linear algebra supplies the first exact language for lost information. Observation and target maps are compared through kernels, quotient spaces, projections, singular values, and weighted inner products. The rank of the target restricted to discarded directions measures the number of missing local coordinates.

  1. Linear information maps
  2. Quotients and factorization
  3. Matrix tools for computation
  4. Weighted geometry
  5. Hidden directions and repair
→
I-03

The Boundary Between Exact and Local Sufficiency

Exact sufficiency requires target constancy on every observation fiber. A derivative condition sees only tangent directions at one regular point. Constant-rank coordinates can turn that condition into a local factorization, while disconnected fibers and separate branches can still support different target levels.

  1. Global fiber conditions
  2. Local tangent conditions
  3. Neighborhood factorization
  4. Connected components and branches
  5. Value, sign, and ordering targets
→
I-04

Minimum Information Repair and Feasible Records

Missing dimension gives a lower bound on repair, while data collection imposes a second feasibility problem. Oracle coordinates chosen after seeing the target can differ sharply from records available before the policy or environment is known. Additivity, cost, timing, and measurement constraints determine attainable repairs.

  1. Missing dimension
  2. Lower bounds and constructions
  3. Admissible records
  4. Additive representations
  5. Constrained record dictionaries
→
I-05

Representation Budgets, Singular Values, and Approximation Loss

A representation budget forces approximation. Worst-direction error and distribution-weighted mean-square loss answer different questions and produce different spectral summaries. Continuity restrictions govern nonlinear encoders, while Taylor remainders connect a local spectral frontier to finite policy and state perturbations.

  1. Two loss functions
  2. Linear approximation frontiers
  3. Continuous nonlinear encoders
  4. Width lower bounds
  5. Finite-perturbation error
→
I-06

From Local Derivatives to Global Decoder Risk

Conditional means minimize squared reconstruction loss, and conditional variance measures the remaining risk. Fiberwise derivatives control variation only after geometric and probabilistic conditions are supplied. Poincare inequalities, component means, generator residuals, and graph approximation error form a complete risk certificate.

  1. Optimal decoder loss
  2. Fiberwise energy
  3. Poincare certificates
  4. Component means and residuals
  5. Limits of graph certificates
→

Measurement, Records, and Time

I-07

Measurement Across Environments

Economic objects are often valued under changing prices, conventions, or environments. Scalar transport works only when attained ranges, rankings, and composition remain compatible. Mixed derivatives and bilinear representations measure environment-dependent information that a single recorded value fails to carry.

  1. Objects and environments
  2. Scalar transport
  3. Composition and rankings
  4. Interaction dimension
  5. Normalization and covariance
→
I-08

Target-Directed Record Selection

Record selection begins after conditioning on the source information already retained. Conditional covariance measures residual target risk, while a feasible field dictionary turns free coordinate choice into a combinatorial selection problem. Greedy and exchange procedures require explicit benchmarks and leakage controls.

  1. Fixing source records
  2. Conditional covariance
  3. Free coordinates and field dictionaries
  4. Selection algorithms
  5. Ex ante collection rules
→
I-09

Clock Error and Decision-Relevant Moments

Recorded time W can differ from event time G through displacement U. A decision may require only selected moments of that displacement. Binomial moment recursions recover latent temporal moments, and polynomial losses reveal exactly which clock moments determine an action and its residual loss.

  1. Physical and recorded time
  2. Required independence restrictions
  3. Triangular moment recursions
  4. Decision sufficiency
  5. Moment minimality
→
I-10

Adjoint Bridges Under Clock Uncertainty

An inverse problem can identify a payoff query without recovering the entire latent response. Adjoint equations characterize exact bridges, closures characterize approximable queries, and stability determines estimability. Multiple admissible clocks require a common bridge or a transparent range of decision values.

  1. Inverse problems for queries
  2. Range, closure, and stability
  3. Common bridges
  4. Multiple clocks and cohorts
  5. Finite windows and boundary tails
→

Information Transmission and Learning

I-11

Administrative Handoffs as Statistical Experiments

Policies pass through channels that transform an upstream experiment and may generate new information downstream. Score projection describes information contraction under a Markov handoff. Delay, arrival, measurement, and causal mediation remain separate objects in the resulting stage ledger.

  1. Models of administrative handoffs
  2. Score projection
  3. Information loss and acquisition
  4. Delay and arrival rates
  5. Policy pathways
→
I-12

Target Fisher Information: Identification and Precision

Singular Fisher information permits some targets to remain estimable while structural directions are unidentified. Kernel and range conditions answer identification; pseudoinverse variance answers precision. Gaussian repair and feasible PSD contractions translate those distinctions into record design.

  1. Singular information matrices
  2. Target identification
  3. Precision thresholds
  4. Gaussian repair
  5. Constrained retention menus
→
I-13

Information Budgets, Decision Loss, and Record Allocation

Information design allocates scarce retention and acquisition resources against target-specific decision loss. Local quadratic regret defines the objective, semidefinite constraints describe feasible information, and alternative release schemes carry different likelihoods and cost measures.

  1. Information and decision loss
  2. Retention and acquisition
  3. Retention semidefinite programs
  4. Rounded rate releases
  5. Exact decision samples
→
I-14

Bayesian Archives and Accumulated Information

An archive accumulates directional precision through repeated reports. The number of observations alone can conceal persistent blind directions. Prior precision, data information, target-weighted posterior loss, state persistence, and field labels determine what the archive teaches.

  1. Information in a report
  2. Prior and data precision
  3. Cumulative excitation
  4. Aging records
  5. The meaning of fields
→
I-15

Choosing Reporting Systems for Policy Learning

Institutions balance current operating loss, the cost of changing a reporting system, and the value of information for later targets. Reporting directions can evolve gradually, react to observed content, and create archive externalities for future decision makers.

  1. Operating and learning objectives
  2. Choosing reporting directions
  3. Dynamic adjustment
  4. Content-dependent selection
  5. Institutional interpretation
→

Comparisons Across Models

I-16

Counterfactual Frontiers Across Model Families

Model comparison requires a common response experiment: the same shock, normalization, observed response, target, and support. Family-entry and sign-reversal radii answer different questions. Coverage failure, within-response ambiguity, and held-out prediction failure provide distinct diagnoses.

  1. Common experimental contracts
  2. Family images and fibers
  3. Entry and reversal radii
  4. Three forms of failure
  5. Finite and certified support
→